Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review
Vol 18 No 3 (2023): August
Corporate Law

Erase The Disciplinary Penalty as A Guarantee For Employees to Remove its Effects


Article View
  • Sarmad Jawad Kadhim*
Sarmad Jawad Kadhim
Faculty of Law, University of Sfax, Tunisia *

(*) Corresponding Author
Picture in here are illustration from public domain image or provided by the author, as part of their works
DOI: https://doi.org/10.21070/ijler.v18i3.936
Published July 25, 2023
Keywords
  • Erasure,
  • Disciplinary Penalties,
  • Public Employees,
  • Organizational Relationships,
  • Statutory Relationships
How to Cite
Kadhim, S. J. (2023). Erase The Disciplinary Penalty as A Guarantee For Employees to Remove its Effects . Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review, 18(3). https://doi.org/10.21070/ijler.v18i3.936

Copyright (c) 2023 Sarmad Jawad Kadhim

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Crossref
Scopus
Google Scholar
Europe PMC

Abstract

This scientific article presents a comparative analysis of the erasure of disciplinary penalties for public employees in the context of organizational and statutory relationships with the state. The study explores the historical evolution of terminology used in Iraqi legislation, transitioning from "nullification" to "cancellation" in recent years. Despite variations in nomenclature, the essence of erasure remains consistent across legislations. Notably, the researched laws do not offer a legislative definition of erasure, relying instead on legal texts to regulate its application. Furthermore, the study highlights the role of administrative judiciary in handling erasure cases without providing a specific definition. By examining the goals, methods, and implications of erasure provisions, this research contributes valuable insights to the field of public employment law, aiming to foster stability in public utilities and ensure the efficient functioning of public services.

Highlights:

  • Historical evolution of terminology in Iraqi legislation.
  • Lack of a legislative definition for erasure in researched laws.
  • Role of administrative judiciary in handling erasure cases.

Keywords: Erasure, Disciplinary Penalties, Public Employees, Organizational Relationships, Statutory Relationships

Article View

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

  1. M. M. Afifi, "The Philosophy of Disciplinary Punishment and Its Objectives (Comparative Study)," Ph.D. Thesis, Faculty of Law, Ain Shams University, 1976, p. 396.
  2. The Iraqi legislator, for example, used the term "nullification," while the Egyptian law used "erasure."
  3. M. J. Al-Malt, "Disciplinary Responsibility of the Public Employee," previous reference, p. 386.
  4. M. M. Yaqoot, "Explanation, Disciplinary Procedures in the Public Office, Free Trade Union Professions, and Private Work," Manshaat al-Maarif, Alexandria, 2004, p. 645 and beyond.
  5. S. M. Al-Tamawy, "Administrative Judiciary, Disciplinary Judiciary," previous reference, p. 408.
  6. A. F. Hassan, "The Competent Authority to Discipline Civil Servants in Comparative and Egyptian Legislation," Journal of Administrative Sciences, vol. 7, April 1965, p. 49.
  7. G. F. Mahdi, "Explanation of the State and Public Sector Employees Discipline Law No. 14 of 1991," previous reference, p. 98.
  8. Service Laws No. (103 of 1931, 64 of 1939, and 55 of 1956) were issued in Iraq. Several service laws were issued that dealt with civil service affairs for other employment agencies, such as Foreign Service Law No. 45 of 2008 and University Service Law No. 23 of 2008.
  9. S. M. Al-Tamawy, "Administrative Judiciary - Disciplinary Judiciary," previous reference, p. 369 and beyond.
  10. M. M. Afifi, "The Philosophy of Disciplinary Punishment and Its Objectives," op. cit., 397 et seq.
  11. A. S. Al-Meligy, "Mediator in Social Legislations - Labor Law - Law of the Public Sector Employees System, Social Insurance Law, A Study of the Legislative Texts in Light of the Rulings of Cassation and Jurisprudence Opinion," 2nd Edition Rose Al-Youssef Foundation, Alexandria, 1984, p. 694.
  12. M. H. Al-Desouki, "Guarantees of the Employee Referred for Administrative Investigation," 1, Arab Renaissance House, Cairo, 176, 2011 and beyond.
  13. M. M. Yaqut, "Principles of Administrative Investigation in the Shadow of Disciplinary Violations," previous reference, 272 et seq.
  14. Z. M. al-Najjar, "Disciplining Workers in the Government and the Public Sector," 2nd Edition, Egyptian General Book Organization, Cairo, 1986, p. 249, as well as A. Q. Jaafar, "The Public Job," 2, Arab Renaissance House, Cairo, 2009, p. I. M. Muhammad and S. Al-Tabbakh, "The Modern Encyclopedia in Explanation of the Civil Servant System Law in the State in the Light of Jurisprudence and Jurisprudence," 1,3 The National Center for Legal Publications, Cairo, 2006, p. 406 et seq.
  15. Z. Bouazizi, "Time Limits in the Disciplinary System in the Public Service," previous reference, p. 59. S. T. Mansour, "Administrative Law," previous reference, p. 273-272.
  16. G. F. Mahdi, "Explanation, Provisions of the Discipline Law for State and Public Sector Employees," previous reference, p. 93.
  17. A. Q. Al-Sheikhly, "The Legal System of Disciplinary Punishment," Previous reference, p. 568, as well as Y. Elias, "The Scientific Reference in Explaining the Laws of Civil Service, Discipline, and Civil Retirement," 1, Dar Al-Taqni for printing and publishing, Baghdad, 1984, 233.
  18. O. S. Ghaylan, "Explaining the Provisions of the Law of Disciplining State and Public Sector Employees No. 14 of 1991, as Amended," previous reference, pg. 56.
  19. I. M. Muhammad and S. A. Al-Tabbakh, "The Modern Encyclopedia in Explanation of the Civil Servant System Law in the State in the Light of Jurisprudence and Jurisprudence," 1, 3, The National Center for Legal Publications, Cairo, 2006 AD, pp. 408-409.
  20. M. I. Al-Dasouki, "Guarantees of the Employee Referred for Administrative Investigation," previous reference, pp. 178-179.
  21. "Article 57 of Law No. 112 of 1983 dated December 12, 1983 fixing the general statute of state agents, local public collectivities and public institutions of an administrative nature," in Proceedings of Legal Reference [2], p. 405.
  22. Case No. 212134 Appeal judgment issued on February 28, 2020 unpublished judgment.
  23. A. S. Omran, "Administrative Judiciary," 1, Al-Sanhouri Library, Baghdad, 2008, p. 80; Also M. L. Radi, "Administrative Judiciary," Duhok University Press, 2010, pp. 95-94; M. Al-Mahmoud, "The Judiciary in Iraq 3," The Prince’s House and Library for Legislation and Iraqi Heritage, Baghdad, 2011, p. 127.
  24. Decision of the Legal Codification Bureau No. 132/1972 on 5/27/1972 quoting S. A. al-Hadithi, "The Disciplinary System for State Employees in Iraq – A Comparative Study," Local Administration Press, 1, Baghdad, 1975, pp. 168.
  25. Fatwa No. 42 of 8/6/1980, Al-Jawaqa’ Al-Adliya, p. 22 S. General, previous reference 2, Baghdad, 1980, p. 175.
  26. M. M. Yaqut, "Explanation of the Disciplinary Law for the Job," pp. 645 and beyond; A. S. Badr, "Administrative Investigation and Disciplinary Courts," previous reference, pp. 136 et seq.
  27. M. M. Afifi, "The Philosophy of Disciplinary Punishment," previous reference, p. 402.
  28. "Law No. 1983-112 dated December 12, 1983 fixing the general statute of state agents, local public collectivities and public institutions of an administrative nature," in Proceedings of Legal Reference [3], p. 405.
  29. G. F. Mahdi, "Explanation of the provisions of the State Employees Discipline Law," previous reference, p. 96.
  30. M. L. Radi, "Administrative Law," University Press, Alexandria, 2005, pp. 225 and beyond.
  31. S. T. Mansour, "Administrative Law," previous reference, pp. 402 and beyond.
  32. S. M. Al-Tamawy, "Administrative Judiciary, Disciplinary Judiciary," Ibid., p. 470.
  33. M. M. Afifi, "Philosophy of Disciplinary Punishment and Its Objectives," previous reference, p. 402.
  34. A. S. Badr, "Administrative Investigation and Disciplinary Courts," previous reference, p. 410.
  35. S. M. Al-Tamawy, "Administrative Judiciary, Disciplinary Judiciary," Ibid., pp. 410 et seq.
  36. S. E. El-Sharif and M. Kamoon, "Disciplinary Systems and the Penal in the Public Office," Dar Contributions in the Literature Foundation, 2006, p. 47.
  37. M. H. Al-Zuhairi, "Ending Disciplinary Punishment in Iraqi Law," previous reference, p. 79.
  38. A. Q. Al-Sheikhly, "The Legal System of Disciplinary Punishment," previous reference, p. 567.
  39. G. F. Mahdi, "Explanation of the State and Public Sector Employees Discipline Law No. (14) of 1991," previous reference, p. 98; also for the same author, his author, comments and articles in the scope of public law, previous reference, p. 52.
  40. "State Shura Council Resolution No. 14/1984 on 5/7/1984," in Fatwas of the State Shura Council - prepared by A. al-Jassani, "Fatwas of the State Shura Council 1980-1984," previous reference, pp. 122-123.
  41. M. M. Afifi, "The Philosophy of Disciplinary Punishment and Its Objectives," previous reference, p. 401.
  42. A. AlFattah Hassan, "Discipline in the Public Office," reference Then, previous, p. 310.
  43. S. J. Al-Din, "Public Job Disputes and Appeals Related to Personnel Affairs," previous reference, pp. 356 et seq.
  44. A. S. Badr, "Administrative Investigation and Disciplinary Courts," previous reference, p. 136.
  45. M. H. Al-Zuhairi, "Ending the Disciplinary Punishment of the Public Servant in Iraqi Law," Master Thesis, College of Law, University of Baghdad, 1998, p. 82.
  46. C. A. Al-Bandari, "Disciplinary Penalties," previous reference, p. 562.
  47. "The ruling of the Supreme Administrative Court issued in session 8/10/1970, Appeal No. 190 of the year 21 of the Supreme Judicial Court," p. 179.
  48. C. A. Al-Bandari, "Disciplinary Penalties," previous reference, pp. 562-563.
  49. A. A. Abd al-Salam, "Disciplining the Public Servant in Egypt," previous reference, p. 292 et seq.
  50. R. N. Taha, "Erasing the Imposed Disciplinary Penalties on the Public Employee," previous reference, p. 188.
  51. M. H. Al-Zuhairi, "Ending Disciplinary Punishment in Iraqi Law," previous reference, p. 82.
  52. S. M. Al-Tamawy, "Administrative Judiciary, Disciplinary Judiciary," Ibid., pp. 412 et seq.